Written by babyface (1996)
Performed by toni braxton

Back in the day
When I was younger
I wasn't afraid
Of giving my heart to you
Now and again
I get sentimental
But I know it's just a phase I'm going through
And every time I start to slip
I just remind myself
I need only think of it
I went through so much hell
You say you wanna get things back
The way they used to be
Can you give me one good reason
Why should I darlin'

Why should I care
Why should I care for you
Why should I care
Why should I care for you
Why should I care
Why should I care for you
Why should I care
Why should I care

Back in the day
I should have been wiser
But what can I say
I should have been onto you
But I was afaid
That you'd break my heart in two
Fate would have it that you broke it anyway baby
And every time I close my eyes
I just remind myself
You told about a million lies
You put my heart through hell
And now you wanna get with me
Just for old times sake
Well I am not about to make that same mistake

Hook

You see a girl that you gave all your love
I see a girl you took advantage of
You see a girl that you cannot forget
I see a man that I cannot forgive
Tell me why

Hook

Back in the day when I was young
I wasn't afraid to love
Back in the day
You were the one what was I thinking of
Back in the day
Should have been wiser
Should have been onto you
But I was afraid I make a mistake
No one knows

• 'til You Do Me Right
• A Girl Like You
• A Lover's Holiday
• A Song for Mama
• Ain't Got No Remedy
• All I Ask
• All Night Long
• Always
• Always in My Heart
• And I Gave My Love to You
• Another Sad Love Song
• Anymore
• Anyway
• As
• Baby Baby Baby
• Baby Come to Me
• Baby I
• Babyface - Every Time I Close My Eyes
• Bedtime
• Betcha Never
• Body Talk
• Born in Time
• Boys & Girls
• Can I Stay With You
• Can We Talk
• Can't Get Enough
• Can't Stop
• Can-u-dance
• Candlelight
• Care for Me
• Could You Learn to Love
• Count on Me
• Damn Thing Called Love
• Dear Lie
• Diggin' on You
• Don't Be Cruel
• Don't Cha' Think
• Don't Wanna Love You
• Don't Waste Your Time
• Don't You Deserve Someone
• Dream Away
• Dreamin'
• Dry Your Eyes
• Every Little Bit of My Heart
• Every Little Step
• Eyes of a Stranger
• Fairweaher Friend
• Fall for You
• Find Me a Man
• Fire
• Fly Away
• Follow My Rainbow
• Forbidden Love
• Girl in The Life Magazine
• Girlfriend
• Give U My Heart
• Giving You The Benefit
• Good Enough
• Hard to Say I'm Sorry
• Have I Never
• Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas
• Heat of The Moment
• Here Comes The Pain Again
• Here He Comes Again
• Ho of My Own
• Honey
• How Can I Not Love You
• How Could an Angel Break My Heart
• How Could You Call Her Baby
• How Did He Love You
• How Do You Tell The One
• How Many Times
• How Often
• Humpin' Around
• I Bow Out
• I Don't Understand
• I Don't Want to Be Lonely
• I Don't Want to Know
• I Dream, I Dream
• I Honestly Love You
• I Miss You So Much
• I Still Love You
• I Surrender
• I'll Be There
• I'll Send You Roses
• I'm Ready
• I'm Your Baby Tonight
• If
• If Ever
• If Only in Heaven's Eyes
• In The Late of The Night
• Isn't It Scary
• It Hurts Like Hell
• Jazzy Belle
• Just for a Day
• Just Hold On
• Just My Luck
• Kissing You
• Knocked Out
• Last Night
• Let It Flow
• Let No One Separate Us
• Let's Do It Again
• Let's Get The Mood Right
• Love by Day, Love by Night
• Love Hurts
• Love Shoulda Brought You Home
• Love Will Be Waiting
• Love Will Be Waiting at Home
• Loves Been So Nice
• Melt Away
• Miracle
• Missing You
• My First Night With You
• My Funny Valentine
• My Heart is Calling
• My Love, Sweet Love
• My Name is Not Susan
• My, My, My
• Never
• Never Forget You
• Never Gonna Let You Go
• Never Love You
• No Deposit, No Return
• No Doubt About Love
• Not Gon' Cry
• Nothin
• On Our Own
• On The Line
• One Love
• Ordinary Girl
• Pants Off
• Power of The Dream
• Pretty Girl
• Pretty Little Girl
• Pride Joy
• Queen of The Night
• Ready or Not
• Reason for Breathing
• Rebel
• Red Light Special
• Rock Wit'cha
• Roni
• Roses Are Red
• Sadder Than Blue
• Sara Smile
• Saved for Someone Else
• Sayonara
• Secrets
• Seven Whole Days
• Shock Dat Monkey
• Sittin' up in My Room
• Slow Jam
• Slow Jams
• So Hard to Say Goodbye
• So Many Thangz
• So Sexual
• Someone to Love
• Somethin' You Wanna Know
• Something in Your Eyes
• Southern Girl
• Sprung on It
• Superwoman
• Sweet November
• Swing It
• Take a Bow
• Tears
• Tell Me Where
• That Somebody Was You
• That's All I Want
• The Best of Love
• The Impossible Dream
• The Lover in Me
• There's No Me Without You
• These Are The Times
• This is How It Works
• Time to End The Story
• Treat You Right
• True Colors
• True Lovers
• Truly Something Special
• Turn Down The Lights
• Until You Come Back
• Water Runs Dry
• We're Making Whoopee
• We're Not Making Love No More
• Wey U
• What U R 2 Me
• Whatever
• When You Believe
• Where is My Love?
• Where You Are
• Why
• Why Do I Believe
• Why Does It Hurt So Bad
• Why Me
• Why Should I Care
• With All My Heart
• Word to The Badd!!
• You Are The Man
• You Can't Run
• You Got The Love I Want
• You Mean The World to Me
• You Said, You Said
• You Were Loved
• You'll Never Stand Alone
• You're Makin' Me High
• Young Girl