Music: samuel barnes, jean claude olivier, cory rooney, tonino bailardo, nicolas reyes
Lyrics: cory rooney, jennifer lopez

I've been so caught up in the thought of me and you
Even though I love someone else
I know my heart belongs to you
Tell me how did we ever let the situation get this far
Maybe we should just try to hide the things we feel inside
Things I know we can't deny

Chorus:
Should've never told you that I cared about you
Didn't think that it would be, so bad
Should've never kissed you
Should've never held your hand
Got to find a way to let these feelings go
What did I do the day I let you slip into my soul
It was then, when I realized that I would always want you in my life
No one else can know of the things that we've been saying on the telephone
It would be so bad
If they ever knew that me and you were secretly into each other

Chorus

Bridge:
I'm so scared, trembling inside
'cause I'm feeling like somebody else already knows
Oh my god, I love you both so much
And to have to choose between the two is hurting me so deep inside

Chorus:
Should've never told you that I cared about you
Never thought that it would be, so bad, hum
Should've never kissed you
Should've never held your hand
I don't ever want to feel this way again

• Could This Be Love
• Feelin' So Good
• If You Had My Love
• It's Not That Serious
• Let's Get Loud
• No Me Ames
• Open Off My Love
• Promise Me You'll Try
• Should've Never
• Talk About Us
• Too Late
• Una Noche Mas
• Waiting for Tonight