Well, she picked me up in a German car
And she took me out to an Irish bar
Where I drank some beer in a plastic cup
Till I had some trouble standing up

And then she drove downtown to a strobe-lit place
Where all wore the guys wore chains and the thumping bass
Was so intense I could barely feel my face
And I think I asked her back to my place

But that's all I recall
And when I woke up in the hall
I was alone and softly groaning
And I'd lost my keys and lost my phone

And I wondered what I did or said
That I might soon regret
It was the night I can't remember
With the girl I can't forget

Well, I was reeling, watching the ceiling spin
The next evening when my friends walked in
And when I asked them if they knew where I'd been
They didn't speak at first, they only grinned

You see, I'm not the type to get in fights
But that might not have been the case last night
Because they heard that I had a word or two
With a man who asked "Is she with you?"

And if I took it the wrong way
I guess that's not for me to say
Though it seems I might have slipped up
When I offered him some grooming tips

But at least that helps explain
The cuts and bruises on my head
>From the night I can't remember
With the girl I can't forget

And it's all coming back now
Don't know how to react now
Guess I'll let it go
I'm not so sure I want to know

Well, I was back at work at 9:15
When a message popped up on my screen
It said "Pick me up at 8:45,
and we can give it one more try"

And now that I'm with her
The whole thing seems a bit absurd
Though she never fails to tell the tale
Of the time she had to post my bail

And for giving me a second chance
I'm forever in her debt
Since the night I can't remember
She's the girl,
I won't ever forget

• ...Baby One More Time
• Baby I've Changed
• California Sex Lawyer
• Can't Get It Out of My Head
• Chanukah Under The Stars
• Comedienne
• Elevator Up
• Half a Woman
• I Know You Well
• I Want an Alien for Christmas
• I Want You Around
• I'll Do The Driving
• Imperia
• Janice's Party
• Karpet King
• Kid Gloves
• Killermont Street
• Maureen
• Nightlight
• Places
• She's Got A Problem (Live)
• Small Favors
• The Girl I Can't Forget
• The Man in The Santa Suit
• These Days
• Today's Teardrops
• Trains And Boats And Planes
• You're Just Never Satisfied